Page 107 Discussion
Moderator: Outsider Moderators
Re: Page 107 Discussion
Now this is a nice birthday gift. Love the manic smile!
-
- Moderator
- Posts: 983
- Joined: Mon Mar 21, 2011 4:02 pm
Re: Page 107 Discussion
Bargaining power for Alex. If they know where Earth is they don't technically NEED him anymore, it's still good to have him around, but at that point he becomes expendable.Razor One wrote:What exactly is gained by hiding Earth's location to people whom you ostensibly need to buddy up to in order to avoid being bushwhacked by the other guy?
Re: Page 107 Discussion
Doesn't track. If they desire warm diplomatic ties with Earth, delivering him home unharmed would be a massive check in their favour. If they're actually curious as to what we're like, then he's still very much indispensable.fredgiblet wrote:Bargaining power for Alex. If they know where Earth is they don't technically NEED him anymore, it's still good to have him around, but at that point he becomes expendable.
That kind of thinking only really seems to make sense in a "Fuck you, got mine" mentality, which as abrasive as the Loroi seem to be at times, isn't something that they possess. Makes more sense if it were the Umiak instead.
Besides, he's been officially declared an ambassador extraordinary and plenipotentiary. He's officially untouchable unless the Loroi have no concept of diplomatic immunity.
![Image](http://i.imgur.com/AHhUhQj.gif)
SpoilerShow
This is my Mod voice. If you see this in a thread, it means that the time for gentle reminders has passed.
Re: Page 107 Discussion
hi hi
While the Loroi might not decide to ditch Alex the moment they know the location of Earth, the location of one's home planet is still a valuable piece of information, especially when Humanity has precious little to offer the Loroi. Even if they expect that the Loroi will know that information eventually, it's best to try to get something out of it in the process, rather than giving it away for free.
While the Loroi might not decide to ditch Alex the moment they know the location of Earth, the location of one's home planet is still a valuable piece of information, especially when Humanity has precious little to offer the Loroi. Even if they expect that the Loroi will know that information eventually, it's best to try to get something out of it in the process, rather than giving it away for free.
Re: Page 107 Discussion
I can't think of a single historical or fictional example where people desiring diplomatic contact with others have rolled up, said hello, and then played coy with the location of their homeland or capital in order to use it as a bargaining chip for... what?
What does humanity gain by hiding? Time? A few extra months or years? Precisely what could be done in that time that would make the slightest difference? What concessions can Alex extract from the Loroi by hiding the location of Earth? Sooner or later he's going to have to give them a vector to head along to get to Terran Space and when that happens it's game over red rover.
Hiding the location of Earth only works if the intent is to fight the Loroi as enemies, which is more or less the complete opposite of what the Bellarmine's mission was. Trying to extract concessions by holding back on that information would only make Alex look dishonest and slimy; not the best impression there considering the dim view the Loroi take on dishonesty.
What does humanity gain by hiding? Time? A few extra months or years? Precisely what could be done in that time that would make the slightest difference? What concessions can Alex extract from the Loroi by hiding the location of Earth? Sooner or later he's going to have to give them a vector to head along to get to Terran Space and when that happens it's game over red rover.
Hiding the location of Earth only works if the intent is to fight the Loroi as enemies, which is more or less the complete opposite of what the Bellarmine's mission was. Trying to extract concessions by holding back on that information would only make Alex look dishonest and slimy; not the best impression there considering the dim view the Loroi take on dishonesty.
![Image](http://i.imgur.com/AHhUhQj.gif)
SpoilerShow
This is my Mod voice. If you see this in a thread, it means that the time for gentle reminders has passed.
Re: Page 107 Discussion
hi hi
"Hey, where is your home planet by the way?"
"If I tell you, will you promise not to blow us all up?"
"I can't rule out blowing up your industrial infrastructure, but ok, we won't exterminate your species."
"Well, that's better than nothing."
I don't know, maybe some assurances that they won't bombard the planet on a whim? I mean, we as viewers know a lot about the Loroi, but Alex is only just starting to get the basics down. As far as he knows, he might yet discover a good reason why humanity should not ally with the Loroi. He's not even sure yet that the Loroi are interested in diplomatic contact.in order to use it as a bargaining chip for... what?
"Hey, where is your home planet by the way?"
"If I tell you, will you promise not to blow us all up?"
"I can't rule out blowing up your industrial infrastructure, but ok, we won't exterminate your species."
"Well, that's better than nothing."
Re: Page 107 Discussion
If you want to play it safe, then sure, shut up about where you live and say nothing. The Loroi won't have any reason to trust Alex on anything he says, and his mission winds up as a failure. He dies of old age in Loroi hands, a mere curiosity, as the Umiak drive humanity into extinction and death.
The mission was never about making a safe choice; it's a risky one with potential benefits. If the idea was to remain hidden for as long as possible, then sending out a mission of diplomatic contact was exactly the wrong thing to do. Concealing the location of Earth just to wring out concessions that can never be enforced and can be rescinded at the drop of a hat is a pointless exercise.
The mission was never about making a safe choice; it's a risky one with potential benefits. If the idea was to remain hidden for as long as possible, then sending out a mission of diplomatic contact was exactly the wrong thing to do. Concealing the location of Earth just to wring out concessions that can never be enforced and can be rescinded at the drop of a hat is a pointless exercise.
![Image](http://i.imgur.com/AHhUhQj.gif)
SpoilerShow
This is my Mod voice. If you see this in a thread, it means that the time for gentle reminders has passed.
Re: Page 107 Discussion
I will follow you everywhere you go... EVERYWHERE!fredgiblet wrote:
This information pleases me hooman, give me more!
Re: Page 107 Discussion
He just casually rattled off a technical definition of base dimensions in terms of fundamental physical quantities to 9 digits of precision. She's Listel caste. From her perspective, he started it.novius wrote:Yep, I'd say she is flirting.... consciously or unconsciously, in a nerdy sort of way.
Tempo's probably sitting there thinking "what a pair of nerds".
Re: Page 107 Discussion
hi hi
Since when is "not divulging all useful information immediately," and "trying remain hidden for as long as possible," even remotely equivalent?" How are "choosing to exchange intelligence rather than giving everything away," and "staying totally silent and never saying anything," the same things?
Humanity might not decide to ally with the Loroi. Telling someone, who currently has worse than 50/50 chance of being an enemy, the location of your homeworld might be disastrous. They gave Alex diplomatic status, but the Loroi have made no formal arrangements for diplomatic relations with the Terrans as a whole. The location of inhabited worlds would be an excellent thing to divulge upon the establishment of official diplomatic relations.
Trust has to go both ways. If one's game theory is predicated on "they can break any agreement at any time, so nothing they say can be trusted," how is it that they can expect to be trusted themselves?
Since when is "not divulging all useful information immediately," and "trying remain hidden for as long as possible," even remotely equivalent?" How are "choosing to exchange intelligence rather than giving everything away," and "staying totally silent and never saying anything," the same things?
Humanity might not decide to ally with the Loroi. Telling someone, who currently has worse than 50/50 chance of being an enemy, the location of your homeworld might be disastrous. They gave Alex diplomatic status, but the Loroi have made no formal arrangements for diplomatic relations with the Terrans as a whole. The location of inhabited worlds would be an excellent thing to divulge upon the establishment of official diplomatic relations.
Trust has to go both ways. If one's game theory is predicated on "they can break any agreement at any time, so nothing they say can be trusted," how is it that they can expect to be trusted themselves?
Re: Page 107 Discussion
The person that is sitting two aisles behind Parat Tempo..
Is that Shoe Girl ?? Is she assigned to provide assistance to Alec or Parat Tempo ??
Is that Shoe Girl ?? Is she assigned to provide assistance to Alec or Parat Tempo ??
Re: Page 107 Discussion
If the aliens are putting you in the cookpot, you probably don't want to volunteer any information about your people... but it's kind of hard to imagine that any serious diplomatic talks could begin with one side refusing to state where the nation it represents even is.
Yes, that's Cloud. She's Tempo's clerk, essentially. I figure that no self-respecting honcho of Tempo's rank would go on a jaunt without at least one underling.kclcmdr wrote:The person that is sitting two aisles behind Parat Tempo.. Is that Shoe Girl ?? Is she assigned to provide assistance to Alec or Parat Tempo ??
Re: Page 107 Discussion
hi hi
Only a single page ago, Alex expressed concern about whether the Loroi had any intention of trying to establish contact with humanity. I mean, from Alex's perspective, there's every possibility that Tempo is on the level. But if the Loroi are stalling until they reach Seren, then I feel like there are some things where it might be prudent to consider waiting on until that time as well.
Alex has already seen that the Loroi don't always agree with each other, even though he has a very narrow and brief sample size, and he's heard the line "I wanted to, but it couldn't be helped," several times already. If I were in his shoes, or more specifically borrowing Fireblade's shoes, I would be very curious to know what Tempo's superiors will say, even while believing that she is being honest. His treatment is understandable from Stillstorm's point of view, but from the point of view of a guy who spent the last week in a holding cell, I would be at least a little bit nervous that upon reaching Seren, the last words I would hear would be "Sorry, I wanted to keep you out of the cookpot/forever-holding-cell, but it can't be helped."
((I'm not saying that I don't think there are any assurances that Tempo could give Alex, but I might at least want to establish whether or not she is planning on advocating for contact once they reach Seren.))
That being said, Alex's narration also stated at the beginning of The Battle for the Bellarmine, that he was worried about whether there was anything humanity could offer the Loroi. Were I borrowing Fireblade's shoes, and I had some indication that having access to Terran space would give the Loroi an advantage in the war, I might try to use that as a selling point.
On the other hand, if I were getting the feeling that Terran space being so far away was going to be a liability, I might be trying to scramble to find some other selling point to help offset it. At least, until the issue is pressed.
Also, hooray for Cloud!![Very Happy :D](./images/smilies/icon_e_biggrin.gif)
Only a single page ago, Alex expressed concern about whether the Loroi had any intention of trying to establish contact with humanity. I mean, from Alex's perspective, there's every possibility that Tempo is on the level. But if the Loroi are stalling until they reach Seren, then I feel like there are some things where it might be prudent to consider waiting on until that time as well.
Alex has already seen that the Loroi don't always agree with each other, even though he has a very narrow and brief sample size, and he's heard the line "I wanted to, but it couldn't be helped," several times already. If I were in his shoes, or more specifically borrowing Fireblade's shoes, I would be very curious to know what Tempo's superiors will say, even while believing that she is being honest. His treatment is understandable from Stillstorm's point of view, but from the point of view of a guy who spent the last week in a holding cell, I would be at least a little bit nervous that upon reaching Seren, the last words I would hear would be "Sorry, I wanted to keep you out of the cookpot/forever-holding-cell, but it can't be helped."
((I'm not saying that I don't think there are any assurances that Tempo could give Alex, but I might at least want to establish whether or not she is planning on advocating for contact once they reach Seren.))
That being said, Alex's narration also stated at the beginning of The Battle for the Bellarmine, that he was worried about whether there was anything humanity could offer the Loroi. Were I borrowing Fireblade's shoes, and I had some indication that having access to Terran space would give the Loroi an advantage in the war, I might try to use that as a selling point.
On the other hand, if I were getting the feeling that Terran space being so far away was going to be a liability, I might be trying to scramble to find some other selling point to help offset it. At least, until the issue is pressed.
Also, hooray for Cloud!
![Very Happy :D](./images/smilies/icon_e_biggrin.gif)
-
- Moderator
- Posts: 983
- Joined: Mon Mar 21, 2011 4:02 pm
Re: Page 107 Discussion
Shoe Girl is Best Girl.
- Count Casimir
- Moderator
- Posts: 217
- Joined: Sat Mar 05, 2011 7:50 pm
Re: Page 107 Discussion
In the current situation, where the Loroi look like the lesser evil (although it is not up to Alex to decide that, and the truth of everything he saw and witnessed may be questionable),
it may be advantageous to have the Loroi know the general direction, so that they can watch for possible attacks of the Umiak in that direction and counterattack that. To prevent the Umiak from reaching the TCA space.
Anyway, it is hypothetical, as the instructions to The Gardener seems to be clear: to not divulge such critical data, and to consider himself lost if the Bellarmine does not return on time, as rescue missions are outside the scope of interest of Humanity. You are on your own if you miss the "window" for return.
I am very curious to learn what the Loroi will do once Alex reaches Seren and his medical data collected on the Tempest will be transferred for scrutinising by the proper departments on Seren.
And possible medical checks before they let him down into their biosphere (as some pathogens inside him may infect Seren, as well as some pathogens on Seren may kill him).
-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-
Also love Beryl's expression.
It's a pity the discussion is not two-sided. She just listens and stores for future reference.
She is asking, yes, but only for "hard data", and not why Humaniti has chosen this reference value over others with rounder numbers.
Her smile may be because she is checking in her head against the data known from the salvaged ship, and through her telepathic connection with experts who analysed the computers salvaged from Bellaramine's wreck, and are possibly right now very happy as Alex is providing key elements to understanding the system.
We will read sooner or later what the Loroi are up to, but Beryl feels very needed and useful.
And possibly knowing that her chest of knowledge now is singular in Loroi space, and thus very valuable, thus possibly earning her a rank or three for having been on the right ship at the right time.
it may be advantageous to have the Loroi know the general direction, so that they can watch for possible attacks of the Umiak in that direction and counterattack that. To prevent the Umiak from reaching the TCA space.
Anyway, it is hypothetical, as the instructions to The Gardener seems to be clear: to not divulge such critical data, and to consider himself lost if the Bellarmine does not return on time, as rescue missions are outside the scope of interest of Humanity. You are on your own if you miss the "window" for return.
I am very curious to learn what the Loroi will do once Alex reaches Seren and his medical data collected on the Tempest will be transferred for scrutinising by the proper departments on Seren.
And possible medical checks before they let him down into their biosphere (as some pathogens inside him may infect Seren, as well as some pathogens on Seren may kill him).
-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-
Also love Beryl's expression.
It's a pity the discussion is not two-sided. She just listens and stores for future reference.
She is asking, yes, but only for "hard data", and not why Humaniti has chosen this reference value over others with rounder numbers.
Her smile may be because she is checking in her head against the data known from the salvaged ship, and through her telepathic connection with experts who analysed the computers salvaged from Bellaramine's wreck, and are possibly right now very happy as Alex is providing key elements to understanding the system.
We will read sooner or later what the Loroi are up to, but Beryl feels very needed and useful.
And possibly knowing that her chest of knowledge now is singular in Loroi space, and thus very valuable, thus possibly earning her a rank or three for having been on the right ship at the right time.
Re: Page 107 Discussion
To me, from Alex' dutyfully-memorized text in page 107, its pretty clear the planners 'back home' were willing to divulge those data to any of the two belligerents when they're willing to talk.icekatze wrote:Only a single page ago, Alex expressed concern about whether the Loroi had any intention of trying to establish contact with humanity. I mean, from Alex's perspective, there's every possibility that Tempo is on the level. But if the Loroi are stalling until they reach Seren, then I feel like there are some things where it might be prudent to consider waiting on until that time as well.
Sofar he clearly divulged only what the contact protocol described. At least, that's what his 'thought bubbles' throughout the comic convey to us.
![Image](https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/49128134507_1639c0cfe0_t.jpg)
Re: Page 107 Discussion
Well, they're definately the cuter evil.Krulle wrote:In the current situation, where the Loroi look like the lesser evil (although it is not up to Alex to decide that, and the truth of everything he saw and witnessed may be questionable)
Who are we kidding, unless Humaniti changed a lot, then the choice between blue space amazon warrior elves and overgrown bugs would be a no-brainer for the majority of the population. Loroi would have to feed on babies or something to sway the public opinion in favor of Umiak.
Well, you get a broad description first, and only when you've got enough general knowledge you go into the details. Heck, I can spend a considerable amount of time talking about ... well, time. However as time is limited (I'm guessing Alexander will be quite occupied once they reach the destination and Beryl is acutely aware of this), this is a gloden opportunity for Beryl to get to know as much as possible. While the history of time measurement is quite fascinating, it may not be the best ... time to dwell on the details. Also there's the possibility that Alexanders knowledge on the subject is broad but shallow.Krulle wrote:She is asking, yes, but only for "hard data", and not why Humaniti has chosen this reference value over others with rounder numbers.
-
- Moderator
- Posts: 983
- Joined: Mon Mar 21, 2011 4:02 pm
Re: Page 107 Discussion
"You know...babies are over-rated..."rewik wrote:Loroi would have to feed on babies or something to sway the public opinion in favor of Umiak.
She can probably guess, based on the similarity, that the second and the solon are based on the same thing. It's likely that Alex doesn't have encyclopedic knowledge of the minutia of why our measurements are the exact values they are.Krulle wrote:It's a pity the discussion is not two-sided. She just listens and stores for future reference.
She is asking, yes, but only for "hard data", and not why Humaniti has chosen this reference value over others with rounder numbers.