Miscellaneous Umiak/misc. races question-and-answer thread

Discussion regarding the Outsider webcomic, science, technology and science fiction.

Moderator: Outsider Moderators

User avatar
Grayhome
Posts: 550
Joined: Fri Apr 22, 2011 2:11 am

Re: Miscellaneous Umiak/misc. races question-and-answer thre

Post by Grayhome »

I still think that you are too negative.
Dragoongfa the comic tells a story of genocide, the enslavement of species, planetary bombardments, mind rape, casual murder of civilians on a massive scale, and that's just the opening act. It's hard for me to see that in a positive light.

It's a GREAT story and I love Outsider, but this universe is pretty grimdark, with touches of nobledark here and there.

User avatar
icekatze
Posts: 1399
Joined: Sat Mar 05, 2011 8:35 pm
Location: Middle of Nowhere
Contact:

Re: Miscellaneous Umiak/misc. races question-and-answer thre

Post by icekatze »

hi hi

I figured that Outsider tells a story of an outsider in a foreign culture. Mentioning some event that happened before the story even began does not exactly make a story about that event, any more than some random vulcan in Star Trek mentioning Humanity's violent past makes Star Trek a grim dark setting.

Outsider has some elements that are dark, but it is way too heroic to be grimdark. There's no inherent sense of fatalism or hopelessness about changing the character's fate for the better, it isn't anywhere close to cynical or disillusioned.

User avatar
dragoongfa
Posts: 1920
Joined: Mon Jan 26, 2015 9:26 pm
Location: Athens, Greece

Re: Miscellaneous Umiak/misc. races question-and-answer thre

Post by dragoongfa »

Grayhome wrote:
I still think that you are too negative.
Dragoongfa the comic tells a story of genocide, the enslavement of species, planetary bombardments, mind rape, casual murder of civilians on a massive scale, and that's just the opening act. It's hard for me to see that in a positive light.

It's a GREAT story and I love Outsider, but this universe is pretty grimdark, with touches of nobledark here and there.
I just think that you let the dark parts of the setting unduly color the brighter ones. Remember that the Barsam 'sacrificed' their independence so they could be a voice of pacifism in the Loroi Union and somehow limit the damage of the hamfisted actions of the Loroi. From my point of view they are a noble society who practice what they preach.

User avatar
Grayhome
Posts: 550
Joined: Fri Apr 22, 2011 2:11 am

Re: Miscellaneous Umiak/misc. races question-and-answer thre

Post by Grayhome »

Remember that the Barsam 'sacrificed' their independence so they could be a voice of pacifism in the Loroi Union and somehow limit the damage of the hamfisted actions of the Loroi. From my point of view they are a noble society who practice what they preach.
And from my point of view the Barsam were obviously telepathically manipulated by the Loroi into convincing other races to give up their sovereignty and resources to the Loroi and disband their collective military. I think we already have more than enough evidence to accuse the Loroi of such telepathic foul play given our knowledge of the Golim and seeing firsthand what the first Loroi did to the first Human she met in the first second of meeting him.

That the Barsam are a species which is nominally devoted to peace while simultaneously aiding and abetting a species who is dedicated toward total war is... comically ignoble to me. One natio claiming to be peaceful when they are engaged with another nation during the middle of a war is... absurdly hypocritical, if not outright insane.

I don't think we're going to see eye to eye on this subject Dragoongfa, we'll have to wait for the story to play out.

User avatar
icekatze
Posts: 1399
Joined: Sat Mar 05, 2011 8:35 pm
Location: Middle of Nowhere
Contact:

Re: Miscellaneous Umiak/misc. races question-and-answer thre

Post by icekatze »

hi hi

There's no evidence at all that the Loroi were involved in a massive scale telepathic manipulation of the Barsam population. The Loroi don't even particularly like the Barsam's political philosophy.

As long as you can acknowledge that you're just making stuff up out of whole cloth, I guess that's cool though.

User avatar
Grayhome
Posts: 550
Joined: Fri Apr 22, 2011 2:11 am

Re: Miscellaneous Umiak/misc. races question-and-answer thre

Post by Grayhome »

There's no evidence at all that the Loroi were involved in a massive scale telepathic manipulation of the Barsam population.
&
As long as you can acknowledge that you're just making stuff up out of whole cloth, I guess that's cool though.
As I just stated, the Loroi treatment of the Golim and their treatment of Alex are more than enough reason to assume the worst. The Loroi have no need to manipulate entire populations of Barsam, or any species. A few individuals and leaders would more than suffice to convince the populations to fall in line, especially if the Barsam, like the loroi, were a feudal society were power was concentrated in the hands of a very few. Mind control the king and you get the kingdom. Easy.

Icekatz it's been... what, a decade since the comic started? At this point speculation about the story isn't really that crazy.
The Loroi don't even particularly like the Barsam's political philosophy.
Utterly irrelevant. The Barsam (along with any species) have resources that the Loroi can use in their war machine.

User avatar
GeoModder
Posts: 1038
Joined: Mon Mar 21, 2011 6:31 pm

Re: Miscellaneous Umiak/misc. races question-and-answer thre

Post by GeoModder »

The Loroi appearantly go to great pain to at least keep areas of Golim-chei free of Loroi. It is hardly their fault the species is so susceptible to Loroi telepathy.

And Stillstorm is hardly an influential officer in the greater political picture of the Union/Empire. On the contrary, she was affiliated to the losing faction of the latest power struggle for the imperial throne, and likely still feels embittered towards her 'masters'. And her actions were almost at first opportunity apologized for towards Alex by the diplomatic officer under her command.

While the Loroi political dealings with other species sofar indeed come over arrogant, they did NOT in general start hostilities to those species that crossed their interests. The Empire/Union more or less formed by accident because of the tenacity Loroi employed in defeating those who attacked them.
Image

User avatar
icekatze
Posts: 1399
Joined: Sat Mar 05, 2011 8:35 pm
Location: Middle of Nowhere
Contact:

Re: Miscellaneous Umiak/misc. races question-and-answer thre

Post by icekatze »

hi hi

Speculation is one thing. Stating that the speculation is obviously the truth unless proven otherwise is, well, an extraordinary claim without extraordinary evidence to back it up. At best it sounds like an appeal to possibility, but it honestly sounds more like a Nirvana Fallacy in progress. Just because someone isn't 100% perfect, doesn't mean they're 100% monstrous.

On the other hand, the Barsam appeared to be a driving force in creating the union and, in the process, managed to convince the Loroi to change their own policy in the process, which seems more like a traditional compromise rather than a overt take-over.

User avatar
Razor One
Moderator
Posts: 562
Joined: Thu May 12, 2011 3:38 pm

Re: Miscellaneous Umiak/misc. races question-and-answer thre

Post by Razor One »

Grayhome wrote:
As I just stated, the Loroi treatment of the Golim and their treatment of Alex are more than enough reason to assume the worst. The Loroi have no need to manipulate entire populations of Barsam, or any species. A few individuals and leaders would more than suffice to convince the populations to fall in line, especially if the Barsam, like the loroi, were a feudal society were power was concentrated in the hands of a very few. Mind control the king and you get the kingdom. Easy.
The Golim are hypersensitive to the Loroi's telepathy and actively seek out such contact when removed from it. The Loroi feel embarassed about this and go to pains to ensure that there are established free zones on their planet where no Loroi may tread. How exactly is this nefarious behaviour on their part?

Alex's initial treatment was done under the entirely reasonable assumption that he was some kind perfidy on the part of their enemy. That he was recovered in combat zone under combat conditions and the fact that the Umiak are known to fight dirty factors into all of this. Any reasonable commander would be suspicious under such circumstances. Even allowing that Stillstorms actions were unconscionable, the Loroi's history evidences the fact that soldiers make for terrible diplomats to the point that they have a specialised caste specifically for such a function and her first action upon getting a handle on the situation was "Shit, our bad, the commander fucked up and is too dumb to realise it, have some diplomatic status on my part and I'll keep her off your back."

The rest is only so much paranoid blather. The mesmerisation of the Golim does not read like out and out mind control. Even assuming that the Loroi were at all capable of pulling such a thing off on influential Barsam to take control of their culture, they'd need to keep up the act for decades, do so in a manner where they wouldn't be noticed, and basically play a Barsam exactly like a Barsam, and not a marionette with a puppeteer above it chuckling to themselves saying "Dance puppets! Dance!"

It basically reads like a bad conspiracy theory. The Loroi are all powerful, all competent, never caught, and have powers they've never been shown to actually have, whilst everyone else is stupid and easily duped, WAKE UP SHEEPLE!

If you're trolling, then well done sir, you done got me good. If you honestly believe your assertions though, I'm probably going to have to stop taking you seriously. It's fine to criticise the Loroi for what they are, but straw manning them just so you can knock 'em down is not a thing I can really respect.
Image
SpoilerShow
This is my Mod voice. If you see this in a thread, it means that the time for gentle reminders has passed.

User avatar
Siber
Posts: 362
Joined: Sun Mar 06, 2011 5:10 pm

Re: Miscellaneous Umiak/misc. races question-and-answer thre

Post by Siber »

The rest is only so much paranoid blather. The mesmerisation of the Golim does not read like out and out mind control.
And even if it were, it is unique. There's no mention I can see in the telepathy article about this kind of mind control even in Loroi vs Loroi combat, which seems like a place it'd come up if it was possible anywhere. What was done to Alex seems to effectively be mental torture, breaking down a target's ability to control their own mental state so that it's easier to surface specific information for reading. While some kind of brainwashing or implanted suggestions MIGHT be possible under those circumstances, that still seems very hypothetical and would require the Loroi to capture and effectively torture the subject without anyone noticing. Doing that to a persuasive set of a civilization's leaders seems pretty long odds.

Put another way, this kind of stunt seems like it requires the Insider to lie by omission. That seems quite out of character for it, at least in my estimation.
Atomic Space Race, a hard sci-fi orbital mechanics puzzle game.
Homeworld Fulcrum, a Homeworld Remastered Mod

User avatar
Grayhome
Posts: 550
Joined: Fri Apr 22, 2011 2:11 am

Re: Miscellaneous Umiak/misc. races question-and-answer thre

Post by Grayhome »

I guess we'll just have to watch as the story unfolds. :roll:

User avatar
dragoongfa
Posts: 1920
Joined: Mon Jan 26, 2015 9:26 pm
Location: Athens, Greece

Re: Miscellaneous Umiak/misc. races question-and-answer thre

Post by dragoongfa »

Siber wrote:
The rest is only so much paranoid blather. The mesmerisation of the Golim does not read like out and out mind control.
And even if it were, it is unique. There's no mention I can see in the telepathy article about this kind of mind control even in Loroi vs Loroi combat, which seems like a place it'd come up if it was possible anywhere. What was done to Alex seems to effectively be mental torture, breaking down a target's ability to control their own mental state so that it's easier to surface specific information for reading. While some kind of brainwashing or implanted suggestions MIGHT be possible under those circumstances, that still seems very hypothetical and would require the Loroi to capture and effectively torture the subject without anyone noticing. Doing that to a persuasive set of a civilization's leaders seems pretty long odds.

Put another way, this kind of stunt seems like it requires the Insider to lie by omission. That seems quite out of character for it, at least in my estimation.
Arioch has confirmed it that what Alex went through was Telekinetic water-boarding, not a telepathic intrusion.

discord
Posts: 629
Joined: Thu Mar 24, 2011 7:44 am
Location: Umeå, Sweden

Re: Miscellaneous Umiak/misc. races question-and-answer thre

Post by discord »

Greyhome: just saying that the US did not create ISIS since they were murdering torah thumping crazies before anything the US did in Iraq, what happened as often does in such situations was a time of patriotism and 'get rid of the foreign monsters!' which was well capitalized by those crazies, the US did not really help the situation, but they did not create it.

and militarily speaking both Iraq 1&2 were halfway competently handled, the occupation was a clusterfuck though.

after a few years of everyone complaining and no one wanting them there the US said 'Well fuck it!' and threw the world police badge on the ground and went home.
the current situation is basically what every bleeding heart liberal was asking for when they said 'US out of Iraq!' and now they are complaining about the results.

majorminor
Posts: 20
Joined: Mon Aug 17, 2015 9:23 pm
Location: Georgia, United States

Re: Miscellaneous Umiak/misc. races question-and-answer thre

Post by majorminor »

That's a bit of a simplification of all the issues that lead to the status of Iraq today.

The disbanding of the Iraqi military post invasion, The general issues that make up the chain of command in the Iraqi military, Sunni-Shia conflicts in both government and in general, the list goes on and on....

The United States couldn't stay there forever, hence why it elected a representative that made those political promises of pulling out. Wars are easy to sell, occupations not so much.

discord
Posts: 629
Joined: Thu Mar 24, 2011 7:44 am
Location: Umeå, Sweden

Re: Miscellaneous Umiak/misc. races question-and-answer thre

Post by discord »

major: and this is why colonialism isn't always such a bad idea, funny thing about that since the US is pretty much the only country in the world still doing it.

ISIS is a threat to civilization as we know it, it says so in their manifesto, convert to Islam or die, surrender your country and all it's resources to ISIS or die, so why do we(international community) allow these buggers to exist? the Russians do not like them, several EU members(especially the french) do not like them at all, the US do not like them, the Japanese rewrote their bloody constitution so they legally could do something about them, the Turks are sick'n'tired of their antics and want to wipe'em out, just to mention a few.


compared to these buggers the Umiak seem like rather benign and friendly masters and lords.

heck compared to these ISIS fellows Nazi Germany seem like a humanitarian and downright good neighbor.
although the Germans were quite a bit more competent at the time.

Krulle
Posts: 1413
Joined: Wed May 20, 2015 9:14 am

Re: Miscellaneous Umiak/misc. races question-and-answer thre

Post by Krulle »

Where will you draw the line what is acceptable and what not?
I agree, we need to get rid of the IS.

But the Turks use the IS to get rid of Bashar al-Assad, and use attacks against the IS as a pre-text to actually bomb the Curdish militia, the only working groundforce against the IS, which has been actively strengthened by the alliance....

It is not black-and-white.
Vote for Outsider on TWC: Image
charred steppes, borders of territories: page 59,
jump-map of local stars: page 121, larger map in Loroi: page 118,
System view Leido Crossroads: page 123, after the battle page 195

majorminor
Posts: 20
Joined: Mon Aug 17, 2015 9:23 pm
Location: Georgia, United States

Re: Miscellaneous Umiak/misc. races question-and-answer thre

Post by majorminor »

Wars and any related occupations cost time, money, resources, and political will. Wars between conventional forces and normal governmental entities are much easier than dealing with a conflict in multiple countries with numerous combatants and several backers each seeking a different end game for the region as a whole. If all the major players regionally and globally weren't at odds over many different related and unrelated issues, a more concise plan in dealing with IS and general stability issues facing the Middle East would be put in place. That is not the case for we are a stubborn lot who's nations and groups are all fighting for their own reasons and goals.

Absalom
Posts: 718
Joined: Sat Sep 24, 2011 4:33 am

Re: Miscellaneous Umiak/misc. races question-and-answer thre

Post by Absalom »

discord wrote:major: and this is why colonialism isn't always such a bad idea, funny thing about that since the US is pretty much the only country in the world still doing it.
The good news is that we phone it in (bases, bases, everywhere, and none of that empire baggage to drag them down), the bad news is that we phone it in (if we use shock-and-awe, a replacement government will magically be spawned by pixie dust!). Our current colonialism techniques clearly suck when used for anything stronger than a slight nudge.
discord wrote:the Japanese rewrote their bloody constitution so they legally could do something about them,
If you mean the stuff they did/are doing this year, I believe that's aimed at China, actually. That, and Koizumi (it's Koizumi, right?) clearly has empathy for the nationalists.

Krulle wrote:Where will you draw the line what is acceptable and what not?
I agree, we need to get rid of the IS.

But the Turks use the IS to get rid of Bashar al-Assad,
In the defense of the genocidal-within-living-memory Turks, al-Assad really probably needs to get taken out by someone before Syria at least will be capable of calming down. We can only get a few dozen anti-ISIS guys trained because everyone is either terrified of post-Assad genocide, or is ticked off at current-Assad oppression. Unless we plan to work with him, any near-term peace will depend on working without him.

Krulle
Posts: 1413
Joined: Wed May 20, 2015 9:14 am

Re: Miscellaneous Umiak/misc. races question-and-answer thre

Post by Krulle »

What I wanted to point out is, that the Turks don't have a plan, and interfere on all possibilities: they want to get rid of al-Assad, so they help the IS, or at least don't block them. They want to get rid of the strongest and currently most organised force against the IS too.
That is a call for desaster...

As far as our western European media, the Curdish treat any non-Curish people rather fairly (maybe only to no anger the ones delivering weapons), while most other militias definitely try to get rid of anyone not from their group in the zones they control....
If you don't want the Curdish, then there is no other force that is able to gain power that would be better than al-Assad....

And the Curdish limit their activities to any regions where they can expect to have future support by the population.
They already built up infrastructure for a working economy once, they know how important it is for a long term future (which I do not see with all other militias, and definitley not with the IS, who are bulding fiefdoms within their sphere of influence), and it is one with included non-Curdish minorities. The Curdish seem to have proven what they can and will do, and seem to know their limits.
Vote for Outsider on TWC: Image
charred steppes, borders of territories: page 59,
jump-map of local stars: page 121, larger map in Loroi: page 118,
System view Leido Crossroads: page 123, after the battle page 195

User avatar
dragoongfa
Posts: 1920
Joined: Mon Jan 26, 2015 9:26 pm
Location: Athens, Greece

Re: Miscellaneous Umiak/misc. races question-and-answer thre

Post by dragoongfa »

From this answer

http://www.well-of-souls.com/forums/vie ... 473#p20473

Vat-growing a person isn't possible at this tech level. They could tinker with the conception process to make more embryos male, but why would they want to do that? There are enough males to keep all of the females constantly pregnant (if that was what they wanted), and if there weren't they could just use artificial insemination. The Loroi don't have a problem with how their system works. They consider the small number of males to be a good thing, since they're essentially economic dead weight.
Considering that both combatants are roughly the same tech level the above comes in conflict with this from the insider:
The Umiak have only a single gender, and while unmodified individuals are still reproductively viable, little is known about the details of their reproductive practices. Indeed, it is suspected that they may have entirely abandoned their natural life cycle; judging by the ease with which they replace losses and their apparent lack of concern for the safety of individuals, it seems likely that the Umiak now rely substantially or wholly on artificial forms of reproduction.
While in page 56 Tempo actually says that many believe that Alex is an artifice of the enemy.

It could be that the Umiak have managed to artificially reproduce due to their unique biological traits but iirc you have mentioned that they have used 'Loroi duplicates' in the past as infiltrators.

On the other hand technological innovation isn't a straight line so they may have mastered the tech early. In the same way that humans had gunpowder projectiles in the middle ages while the Loroi got them in their industrial age.

Post Reply